Alliancing Progress

RoadNotTaken

The Road Not Taken by Robert Frost

Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,
And sorry I could not travel both
And be one traveller, long I stood
And looked down one as far as I could
To where it bent in the undergrowth;

Then took the other, as just as fair,
And having perhaps the better claim
Because it was grassy and wanted wear,
Though as for that the passing there
Had worn them really about the same,

And both that morning equally lay
In leaves no step had trodden black.
Oh, I kept the first for another day!
Yet knowing how way leads on to way
I doubted if I should ever come back.

I shall be telling this with a sigh
Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I,
I took the one less travelled by,
And that has made all the difference.

DHBs and PHOs have by now all formed Alliance Leadership Teams, and in the near future ALTs will form “Service Level Alliance Teams” to provide advice and recommendations about “whole of system” approaches to improvement in services across a range of issues important in their communities – youth health, emergency care, and where appropriate rural providers across the country are being approached to engage in rural service level alliance teams.
This is a huge opportunity for rural providers. For the first time every DHB in the country – yes, even you South Canterbury – is being encouraged to develop an infrastructure that allows rural based providers a significant voice in the planning of sustainable health services for their communities.
At the recent workshop jointly organised by the MOH and NZRGPN (see what we are doing there – this is about working together) we heard the MOH say:
“This funding is to support rural general practice, there is no intention to reduce the financial sustainability of rural practice.”
“If ALTs think this is about making shifts in the way rural bonus is paid they have missed the point, this is about sustainable services for rural communities.”
Somewhere in ages and ages hence, we will tell our trainees with a heavy sigh, “two roads diverged in a wood, and I, I took the one less travelled by, and that has made all the difference.”
But if we are honest, just as for Robert Frost, the choice between the road taken and the alternative was not based on whether or not one was more trodden than another. For us the decision was based on the fact that one branch of the road looked pretty much like the road behind – increasingly fractured and uneven whilst the other had at the very least a few road signs.
At the end of the road whether we reach our destination will depend on how much effort we all put into the journey.
To be successful providers need to engage with the process.
The NZRGPN has on its website an “Alliance 101” link that hopefully will give rural providers a bit of a map to help them on their way. The website provides a link to tools to ensure that communication between the “centre” and rural communities works as best as it can in “rural proofing” – it provides a sample “terms of reference” to guide rural service level alliance teams as to how they should work together and direction for teams to consider principles and values by which they might work.
The website provides links to video summaries of the September Alliance Workshop and information about how these teams will be supported in the future.
The NZRGPN, MOH, DHBs and PHOs will regularly get together to share information and concerns about the sustainability of services to rural communities at the Rural Advisory Group – so even when the road travelled becomes leaf thick and slippery help is on hand to clear the path ahead.
No one relishes change, but the NZRGPN hopes and expects this change will be a positive one for our members and the communities they serve.

New Zealand “Alliance Contracting” Workshop – Sept 4th 2014

Alliancing is one approach that the New Zealand health system can use to efficiently allocate scarce resources through building communities of interest across more than one practitioner or organisation. There are core elements to alliancing that contribute to improving success.

An Alliance reflects a group of organisations agreeing to work together to achieve shared outcomes and using a shared decision-making forum, the Alliance Leadership Team (ALT). The approach provides a more ‘fit for purpose’ arrangement that promotes and facilitates integration, regional service planning, and alliance funding and planning. It provides a mechanism for clinical leaders to be involved in the development of health services.
Service Level Alliances are established by the ALT, as required, to implement significant service change and or specific service redesign. ALTs are decision-making forums for organising groups of related health services, including decisions on contractual mechanisms and budgets.

Who will be involved in a Rural Service Level Alliance?
DHBs, primary health organisations (PHOs) and providers will work together in a Rural Service Level Alliance. They will involve GPs and possibly other health professionals and organisations who deliver a given service. They are likely to engage with patient groups and communities. The range of participants depends on the agreed scope of the discussions.

Workshop Summary:

More than 80 representatives from rural general practices New Zealand-wide, DHBs, PHOs and other allied rural sector organisations attended a workshop in Wellington on September 4 to hear about and discuss the new Alliancing era and its impact on rural communities.
In October 2013, Associate Health Minister Jo Goodhew announced the Government’s support for a new way of allocating rural funding through Service Level Alliances and that additional rural funding would be provided in the form of transitional funding and rural practice sustainability funding.

Alliancing will see DHBs, PHOs and other health providers’ work together in Rural Service Level Alliance Teams. These teams will involve GPs and other health professionals, and organisations and could also involve community representation. Discussions and negotiations will ultimately determine funding levels allocated to rural practices for services provided.
Organised jointly by the New Zealand Rural General Practice Network and the Ministry of Health, workshop delegates gathered at the Rydges Hotel to hear speakers including the Deputy Director-General of the Sector Capability and Implementation Business Unit Cathy O’Malley, Network chairperson Dr Jo Scott-Jones, Network Board members and representatives from Midland Health Network and the Canterbury Clinical Network speak about the Alliancing concept and their experiences of instituting it. During the day delegates participated in workshops, listened to panel discussions and discussed and questioned the Alliancing concept.
New Zealand Rural General Practice Network chairperson Dr Jo Scott-Jones was delighted with the turn-out and with the positive attitude from delegates to embracing the new funding era. He urged them to “get involved” in the process and engage with their peers, communities, allied health services, DHBs and PHOs to ensure the future viability of their practices and services to communities and patients.

Dr Scott-Jones said Alliancing offered a formal infrastructure which would allow rural general practice to look closely at the way it operates alongside PHOs and DHBs.
“We need to be open to how we can “do things better”, so that services in rural communities continue into the future.
“At the same time we need to ensure the current somewhat fragile services are supported and retain their financially viability.”

Key outcomes of the workshop were:
• A MoH assurance that “there is no intent for rural funding to go anywhere other than rural general practice” There has been a lot of anxiety about this amongst providers. The process was much more about the sustainability of services in communities than about the funding.
• If an ALT wants to just talk about changing the “rural premium” funding streams it has missed the point – this is about big picture planning and innovation and is a real opportunity to develop sustainable rural health services
• Examples of Alliancing work already underway around the country provided an opportunity for delegates to hear what had worked well
• Acknowledgement that many rural practitioners, PHOs and DHBs will want to take their time over this process and develop these new relationships with trust and integrity
• The Network will continue to facilitate/share progress related to rural Alliancing
• Key messages and interviews with presenters will be available via the Network’s website: www.rgpn.org.nz